Reading & EatingREAL READER. REAL OPINIONS.Browse all reviews
We Already Dug the Grave by Emma C. Wells cover

KAREN’S BOOK REVIEW

We Already Dug the Grave

★★★☆☆

Reviewed October 26, 2026 · Thriller

It started out strong, with an intriguing premise, good writing, and just the right amount of witchiness for Halloween! Unfortunately, somewhere along the way, it lost me a little. Sisters Milly and Francis are sent to live with their eccentric great-aunts in a small Tennessee town after their mother kills their father and goes to prison. The women in this family have an unusual gift: they can divine the future by reading tea leaves. The townspeople consider them spooky. Milly inherits the family gift, although she's slow to understand it. Very protective of her younger sister, she senses danger before it arrives. But when tragedy strikes, Milly flees to Alabama, cutting herself off from her family for the next decade. One day Francis reappears, now married into a wealthy, prominent family, and desperate for her sister's help. When Milly reads her tea leaves, she sees a terrifying future, and the sisters must confront a danger that threatens to destroy them. I enjoyed the first part of this Southern Gothic thriller. The characters were great and the supernatural elements added enough mystery without overwhelming the story. But as the plot unfolded, there were suddenly too many improbable twists. I found myself questioning things rather than enjoying the twisty ride. Still, there's plenty to appreciate, particularly if you like family secrets, complicated sisters, and a touch of witchcraft. It's a fun read for Halloween, even if it didn't deliver 100%.

♥

Happy reading,
Karen