Reading & EatingREAL READER. REAL OPINIONS.Browse all reviews
An Unlikely Visitor by Joanna Cannon cover

KAREN’S BOOK REVIEW

An Unlikely Visitor

★★★★☆

Reviewed November 21, 2026 · Fiction

A beautifully written, sometimes heartbreaking, but ultimately hopeful story of love, loss, and the possibility that the people we love are always with us. Margaret has recently lost her beloved husband, Derek, and is struggling without him. They had a long, loving marriage, but their lives were changed when their daughter, Jeanie, disappeared forty years ago. They never had more children, never found the answers they desperately needed, and somehow learned to live with unimaginable pain. Now, without Derek by her side, Margaret feels lost. Then something rather extraordinary happens. Margaret begins to sense Derek's presence. At first, she wonders if grief has made her crazy. But eventually, Derek begins appearing to her, and together they embark on an journey to uncover the truth about what happened to Jeanie and their purpose in life. This is where magical realism comes into play, and I loved that aspect of the story. The naysayers have to be willing to suspend disbelief and consider the possibility that there are things in this world we cannot explain. But what makes this book so special isn't just the mystery of what happened to Jeanie. It's everything Margaret discovers along the way. Through Derek's encouragement, she begins to see people around her differently. Neighbors, friends and acquaintances are all carrying their own sadness, disappointments, and struggles. Sometimes the smallest gesture of kindness can make an enormous difference in someone's life. Loved these characters, and Joanna Cannon writes about ordinary people and with warmth and compassion. There is a wonderful message here about the connections we make and the lives we touch every day. No spoilers, but I will say that the ending left me a little confused. Then again, perhaps that's part of the story. Not every question has a perfect answer.

♥

Happy reading,
Karen